• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

Wealth Pilgrim

No Money Worries. No Matter What.

Neal Frankle featured in
  • Home
  • Life Insurance
  • Investing
    • Build Strong Investment Building Blocks To Avoid Going Broke In Retirement
    • Systematic Mutual Fund and ETF Investing
    • Stock Market Investing Guide
    • Choosing the Right Investment Brokerage Guide
    • How Bonds Work Guide
    • How Banks Really Work Guide
    • Annuities – What You Need To Know Before You Invest
    • A Beginners Guide To Buying Individual Stocks
    • Create A Pool Of Great Mutual Funds and ETFs To Pick From To Secure Your Retirement
    • ETF and Index Fund Investment Guide
  • Earn More
  • Credit Cards
    • Travel
    • Airline
    • Hotel
    • Cash Back
    • 0% APR
    • Rewards
    • Balance Transfer
    • Small Business
    • No Annual Fee
    • Student
    • Secured
  • Retirement Planning
    • Retirement Guide
  • Ask Neal a Question
  • Reviews
    • Upgrade Personal Loans Review
    • Lending Club Review
    • Prosper Review
    • Ally Invest TradeKing Review
    • CIT Bank Review
    • LegalZoom Review
    • Lexington Law Review
    • Airbnb Host Review
    • Should You Drive For Uber?
  • Tax
  • Courses
    • Raise Your Credit Score So You Can Buy a House – Free Video Course

A Diversified Portfolio is Risky – Here’s Why

by Neal Frankle, CFP ®, The article represents the author's opinion. This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our disclosures for more info.

Share
Share
Tweet
Pin

Currently the market is disturbingly turbulent. During times like these, some investors think that a diversified portfolio is their key to investment security.  I agree that it might help in certain circumstances.But in other cases diversification can be a very risky approach. That’s right. Often a diversified portfolio will expose you to much more risk than a narrowly focused portfolio would. Before we discuss this, let’s agree on our terms.

What is a diversified portfolio?

Some define a diversified portfolio of growth stocks as one that holds many different stocks in many different industries. A diversified portfolio of  funds would hold a variety of funds invested in small cap, large cap, growth, value and international sectors as well.

Others take the term diversification to mean something else entirely. They require you to have equities, bonds, commodities and real estate in your portfolio in order to consider it diversified.

So before we can agree that diversification increases or decreases risk, we need to agree what diversification is and the investment community hasn’t done that yet.  Lets keep going anyway.

Would you like some help with managing your portfolio?  If so, let me know.  I’d be delighted to answer your questions.

Why do investors like to diversify?

Regardless of how you define it, the idea behind a diversified portfolio is that you should have a wide variety of different investments. That way, if one or two position do poorly, the other holdings might do well and make up for it. It’s the old adage of not having all your eggs in one basket. To the extent that each holding differs from the others your risk decreases according to the proponents.

Of course these arguments are valid – but they don’t tell the entire story. Even though diversification has its benefits, it has its drawbacks too (some of which are very serious and are often overlooked).

1. Watered-Down Returns.

It might be hard to think about making gains right now, but have perspective. Over a long investing career, there are both good and bad years.  By having your money in many different asset classes, your returns are diluted in good years and they tend to outnumber the bad ones.

You could have a handful of big winners but it won’t make that much of a difference if your portfolio is widely diversified. In order to do well you will need many positions with great returns. Here’s a real-world example of a diversified portfolio and the corresponding returns:

diversified portfolio

Now, here’s an example of a more focused portfolio:

diversified portfolio

Admittedly, the past is no guarantee of future results and the time periods are different.  But you can see that a more focused portfolio has the potential for greater returns – as well as greater losses in any one year.

2. No Safe Harbor

If 2008 taught us anything it’s that all ships rise and fall with the tide.  (We’re also getting a taste of this right now.) In other words, there are times when most stocks rise in price and there are other times when all stocks most get clobbered. In such circumstances, diversification won’t do many investors any good. Even people who bought real estate and/or commodities got soaked in 2008. And everybody is going through it right now.

Why?  Because asset classes move more and more together in lock-step because of technology and globalization. Consider the Russell 1000 Growth Index and the Russell Value Index 1000. According to Investment News Magazine these indexes use to respond to the market very differently. In fact, between 1990 and 2000 they only moved together 57% of the time. But since 2000 these two indexes now move together 92% of the time. So much for safety in diversification.

And when it comes to international investing, the correlation much better. Emerging markets used to have almost no correlation what-so-ever with the Russell Growth Index. Now these two indexes move and up and down in a similar fashion 89% of the time.

3. False Sense of Security

This is a huge problem especially right now.  Even if you have a diversified portfolio you might be taking some pretty painful hits right now.  Just like people who bought target date or lifecyle funds and incorrectly thought they had a safety net, investors who rely on a diversification strategy for protection ignore the realities of the market. More and more world markets are intertwined with each other as I said above. Having a diversified portfolio in a declining market is like rearranging the deck chairs on the Titanic. No matter what you do, you’re going to get wet.

Rather than rely on diversification to provide safety you must understand two things:

  1. If you invest using diversification as your primary means of reducing investment losses, there will be times when this will not work and you will suffer great losses.
  2. If reducing investment losses is a primary concern should consider alternative investment tactics.

I’ve written about market timing in the past because that is one such alternative. And when I refer to this I am not suggesting that you sit behind a computer terminal and trade stocks all day long. I am not talking about day trading and I am not suggesting you use your gut feeling to guide your investment decisions.

I am talking about using a strategy that measures risk and moves out of the market at one time or another based on a well thought-out strategy. Some market timers move out of the market several times a week. Others move their money in or out of the market a few times a year or once every several years. This depends on the systems they use. Each system has its pros and cons and there is no one market timing strategy that is perfect. Indeed, just because you use market timing, you have no guarantee that you’ll do any better than those investors who employ a diversified portfolio at any given time. Sometimes you’ll do much better. Other times you’ll do much worse.

What this boils down to is that in order to be a successful investor you should really understand what your strategy is engineered to do. There are plenty of benefits to using a diversified approach to investing. But maximizing gains and protection against catastrophic loss are not always guaranteed using this (or any approach). Unfortunately many investors think that diversification does deliver that safety when it doesn’t.

Do you have a diversified portfolio?  Why or why not?  What have your results been recently?

Share
Share
Tweet
Pin

Looking for even more helpful financial investment info?

Subscribe to the Wealth Pilgrim VIP Newsletter!

You will receive bi-weekly updates including helpful articles and exclusive invitations to live Webinars!

Reader Interactions

User Generated Content (UGC) Disclosure: Please note that the opinions of the commenters are not necessarily the opinions of this site.

Comments

  1. Mark says

    June 19, 2012 at 10:07 AM

    Hi Neal,

    Great article and I agree that most asset classes seem to be highly correlated during times of high market volatility. I know you’ve written before that you have a market timing approach you prefer over buy and hold. I’m in the same boat and I sold off most of my portfolio earlier in the year when the market was a fair amount higher, but the market has yet to hit the target low I was hoping to reinvest at. I’d be interested to hear more about your specific timing approach in a follow up article. Thanks!

    Reply
    • Neal Frankle says

      June 19, 2012 at 10:55 AM

      Thanks! I agree w/you Mark. Selling is easier than getting back in. I believe you must be willing to stick to your system – even though it’s not perfect – as long as the long-term results are attractive.

      For more info on one idea using market timing, read this.

      Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Are You Human? * Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

Primary Sidebar

Who is Neal Frankle

Neal Frankle

I'm a Certified Financial Planner™ with more than 25 years of experience. I feel very blessed and hope to share my personal financial experience and professional wisdom with readers of WealthPilgrim.
Read More »

Stay Connected

FacebookTwitterYouTubeRSS

More Categories

Banking
Career Development
College Funding
Credit Cards
Credit Score Fixes
Money and Marriage
Debt Relief
Estate Protection
Property Investment Loans
Small Business Strategies
Spend Less Money

Disclaimer

Wealth Pilgrim is not responsible for and does not endorse any advertising, products or resource available from advertisements on this website. Wealth Pilgrim receives compensation from Google for advertising space on this website, but does not control the advertising selection or content. Please do the appropriate research before participating in any third party offers. The information contained in WealthPilgrim.com is for general information or entertainment purposes only and does not constitute professional financial advice. Please contact an independent financial professional for advice regarding your specific situation. Wealth Pilgrim does not provide investment advisory services and is not a registered investment adviser. Neal may provide advisory services through Wealth Resources Group, a registered investment adviser. Wealth Pilgrim and Wealth Resources Group are affiliated companies. In accordance with FTC guidelines, we state that we have a financial relationship with some of the companies mentioned in this website. This may include receiving payments,access to free products and services for product and service reviews and giveaways. Any references to third party products, rates, or websites are subject to change without notice. We do our best to maintain current information, but due to the rapidly changing environment, some information may have changed since it was published. Please do the appropriate research before participating in any third party offers.


About · Contact · Disclaimer & Privacy policy

Copyright © Wealth Pilgrim 2019 All Rights Reserved